Here is the greatest butternut squash soup recipe I have come across thus far. I took this (and varied it) from a book documenting how to cook every dish from the restaurant Gordon Ramsay at Royal Hospital Road.

The changes are for timing and to reduce complexity, but they would add super amazing flourishes to the dish. I’ll go over those at the end of my basic recipe.
First, what you will need ingredients wise:
- A fully grown (1 - 1 1/4lb) butternut squash
- 2 large shallots
- Double cream / whipping cream (here in Canada that’s 35%)
- ~2 tbsp of butter
- 4-6 cups of vegtable stock (this will vary based on amount of squash)
- 1/4 cup of olive oil (no extra virgin here, folks)
- sea salt and fresh cracked pepper
And here is the kit you will require to make it:
- A saucepan capable of holding all of the squash and stock
- A blender
- A second clean saucepan to pour the soup in to from the blender
- A vegetable peeler of choice
OK, so now you have all of your ingredients, what do you do?
Step 1 - Prep the Squash
Get out that peeler (for my money, one like this is the absolute best for peeling anything) and peel the squash fully.
Now, to do any sort of dicing on a squash, you will absolutely require a very sharp knife - these usually come in the form of an 8” chef’s knife, or something of the like.
Essentially, the first cut you will make is to separate the head from the body, and then proceed to halve the body of the squash. Once you do that, you will notice it has seeds / an apperance very similar to a pumpkin.
Get out a spoon and scoop out all those seeds and those stringy bits. It’s OK if you catch bits and pieces of the flesh of the squash as you are cleaning it.
Now, simply cut (in whatever way you feel is best) the body and head of the sqaush you separated in to cubes - there are plenty of videos on YouTube that can show you exactly how to do this.
Step 2 - Prep and Heat the Shallots
Peel and dice the shallots. Here is a video. Once that’s done, pour your olive oil into a pan and let it heat. Then, get all of the diced shallots in there as well and stir until they start to turn a bit brown.
Step 3 - Cook the Squash
Get all of the squash cubes and put them in to the sauce pan you have been using to cook the shallots. Also, drop in your butter as well and start stirring and mixing.
For this first portion, you want the squash to get to be a SLIGHT bit harder than boiled potatoes. So, you are looking to be able to easily pierce them with a fork and have them slowly slide off the fork - but not to be so cooked they are falling apart off the fork when pierced.
This should take 8-15 minutes, depending on the heat you are using, the pan, etc… You can also season here as you feel is appropriate.
Step 4 - Heat the Stock
Put your veg stock in to another saucepan and heat so that it’s hot. A good test is similar to testing fish fillets for done-ness - put the tip of a fork halfway in the stock and then hold it up to your upper lip. If it feels like a cup of tea / coffee, it’s probably warm enough, but use yor discretion.
Step 5 - Combine
You are now going to want to combine the stock with the squash mixture. Make sure that you have enough stock to submerge the squash - continue stirring occassionally.
Give it a couple of minutes for the flavors to work together, then slowly pour (while stirring) in your cream. Now, leave the mixture to simmer until the squash is soft.
Step 6 - Whiz
Once done, use a slotted spoon to scoop out all of the sqaush from the saucepan and in to the blender. Add about a third of the liquid in which the squash was cooking.
Carefully pulse the contents until you have a smooth and creamy soup consistency. You can add more stock as well if you like to reduce some of the creamy-ness, or add more whipping cream to add additional thickness.
Pour from the blender and in to a clean sauacepan - serve as soon as you can. If you find the soup to be a bit chunky, you can optionally pour it from the blender and in to a second sauce pan by way of a colander.
To Serve
To plate the soup, you can simply put it in to a bowl and serve, seasoned to taste with a drizzle of olive oil. You could also add a drizze of truffle-infused olive oil.
Some of the Gordon Ramsay flourishes / additions include serving with sauteed mushrooms, a parmesan crisp, a seared scallop, and a single hand-made stuffed tortellini.
Photo taken by Rachel Segal.
2 years ago